The Fifth General Order - A Deep Dive Review

by Jonathan A Phillips (Author)

Updated at: 19/02/2025

In The Fifth General Order, Jonathan A. Phillips unveils the harrowing true story of a young Marine unjustly court-martialed and imprisoned. Falsely accused and subjected to brutal solitary confinement, this Lance Corporal endured a two-year ordeal, a scandal reaching the highest levels of the Pentagon during the Iraq War. His fight for justice, aided by a loyal commander and family, exposed a cover-up within the Department of the Navy and Marine Corps, revealing a campaign of dishonor prioritized over truth and loyalty. This gripping narrative details his incredible resilience, his battle against smear campaigns, and his ultimate triumph, serving as a powerful testament to the courage of one man and the systemic injustices faced by some veterans.

5 / 54 ratings

Review The Fifth General Order

"The Fifth General Order" left me utterly speechless, and frankly, still reeling days later. Jonathan A. Phillips’ memoir isn’t just a gripping account of a Marine unjustly accused and imprisoned; it’s a visceral experience that forces you to confront the darkest corners of military bureaucracy and the devastating impact of war on those who fight it.

The sheer audacity of the accusations leveled against Phillips is breathtaking. To witness a young Marine, already physically and mentally scarred from combat in the brutal Sunni Triangle, subjected to a sham court-martial and then tossed into solitary confinement for ten months – denied sunlight, fresh air, anything resembling humane treatment – is infuriating. The book paints a picture of a system so deeply flawed, so willing to sacrifice individual justice for the sake of maintaining appearances, that it’s hard to believe.

But what truly elevates this book beyond a simple exposé is Phillips' unwavering spirit. He doesn't just survive; he fights back. His determination, his dogged pursuit of truth in the face of overwhelming adversity, is nothing short of inspirational. He meticulously documents the injustices, presenting irrefutable evidence that exposes a cover-up that reached the highest echelons of the Pentagon during the Iraq War. The internal documents he shares are gut-wrenching, revealing not just the callous disregard for his well-being, but the extent to which the military was willing to go to protect itself, regardless of the cost to the integrity and lives of its own personnel.

The revelation about the use of hypnotics on frontline troops was particularly disturbing. The idea of young men and women being drugged, their judgment impaired, while facing life-or-death decisions in combat is morally reprehensible. It underscores the chilling indifference some commanders displayed towards the lives of the soldiers under their command. Phillips wasn't just fighting for his own vindication; he was fighting for the countless others who suffered similar fates, silently enduring the physical and psychological wounds of war and the betrayal of a system that was supposed to protect them.

Phillips' account also humanizes the war in a way few books manage. He paints a vivid picture of the camaraderie among his fellow Marines, the fear and uncertainty of combat, and the psychological toll it takes. The description of Iraqi soldiers refusing to fight, leaving the American troops to shoulder an impossible burden, is heartbreaking. It's a stark reminder that war is not just a series of strategic maneuvers; it’s a chaotic, messy, and deeply personal experience that leaves lasting scars on everyone involved.

"The Fifth General Order" is a powerful testament to resilience, courage, and the importance of truth. It's a call to action, demanding accountability and reform within a system that has demonstrably failed its own. This is not simply a story of one Marine’s ordeal; it’s a story of systemic failures, institutional betrayal, and the enduring spirit of a man who refused to be silenced. This is a book that will stay with you long after you turn the final page, a book that demands to be read and shared.

See more: Camouflaged Wounds: My Mental Combat with PTSD - A Deep Dive Review